SE32W
          with 13E1, July 2008.
      
      For those not wanting to read about ancient history dating back to
      2008, they may go to the 
      2012 version
      of SE32 amps. 
      The following history last edited 2017 has valuable info including
      Fig 2 which has all details 
      for a very good SE OPT to suit 1 x 13E1, or 3 x KT88 / 6550. 
      
      In 1997, I built the 22W SEUL amps using a single 13E1 in single
      ended ultralinear mode. 
      The details are well covered in my web page on the SEUL 25W. The SEUL amps
      pleased anyone 
      lucky enough to hear music piped through them. 
      In 2000, I demonstrated the SEUL amp to the Audiophile Society of
      NSW at a Sydney venue. 
      The 30 people present very much enjoyed the experience.
        
      Since 1997, I have increased my experience of using local negative
      feedback in amplifier output 
      stages, with less reliance on global NFB applied from an OPT
      secondary to an input tube cathode 
      in the traditional manner. 
      I first applied the idea of local CFB in SE output stages way back
      in 1994 when upgrading 5W 
      amps in an old stereo AM radio which had EL84 output tubes. I
      applied the idea for a much more 
      powerful SE amp with 4 x EL34 in my
          SE35W monoblocs.
      
      A customer of mine who had bought a pair of SEUL 22W amps had
      borrowed another customer's 
      SE35 amps and he thought the SE35 to be slightly more accurate and
      detailed. It is not uncommon 
      for audiophiles to lend their amps to each other for comparisons
      occasionally. 
      
      I wondered if any better sonic and technical performance could be
      had from the 13E1, and I had 
      suspected it to be possible ever since 1997 but had not fully
      explored the possibilities and 
      practicalities. My customer with SEUL 22 has always found that
      other projects I have built for him 
      resulted in a worthwhile and pleasing outcome so he went ahead
      with the change from the ultralinear 
      operation with screen feedback from  tap on the OPT anode
      primary winding to having the primary 
      divided into two windings with 66% of turns for the anode and 33%
      of turns for the cathode for 
      applied cathode feedback. 
      
      He had also purchased a pair of my Sublime speakers, also
      described in my website page on 
      loudspeakers-new.
      The original SEUL amp was in fact capable of about 22W into 8 ohms
      and about 25W into 4r0. 
      But with 4r0 there was more than twice the THD than with 8r0 and
      because the Sublimes had an 
      impedance of about 5r0 average, I thought a change to the output
      transformer ratio would give a 
      much better load match to the 13E1 and thus reduce the distortion
      and give a higher maximum 
      output power of 32W because of increased anode efficiency with a
      much lower screen dissipation. 
      
      The sound of the new amp circuit is very clear and natural, but
      never clinical or blandly cold, 
      and conveys the recorded warmth of a real live performance to give
      high emotional engagement 
      with music that is the hallmark of a good tubed system. Bass is
      tight and gives the music its 
      foundation, treble is sweet, with midrange that is glorious
      without being "euphonic" - ( a commonly 
      used and vague word used by audiophiles to often describe SE
      Triode amps with little bass, rolled 
      off treble, and no loop FB and some ring tones from vibrating
      microphonic grids/cathodes in directly 
      heated triodes ).  
      Rather than wade through the changes to the SEUL22W schematic in a
      laborious discussion, 
      I will simply provide the SE32 schematic I used and explain how it
      works, with some provisos 
      and notes about limitations etc. People are then free to compare
      the SEUL22W to the SE32 
      schematic, and are free to adopt the principles of the operation.
      
      Tube amp design is somewhat flexible.
      
      Fig1, for 2008 amp. 
      
      Fig1 shows the audio circuit with input V1 6SL7, driver V2 EL34 in
      triode, and output V3 13EI. 
      V1 input stage, 6SL7. 
      C1+R1 form a high pass filter with pole at 7.2Hz to keep out dc or
      very low F signals. 
      V1 Input stage signal is applied to the 6SL7 grids. 
      There is a very mild amount of 9dB of global negative feedback
      from OPT secondary applied to the 
      cathode via FB resistance divider, R5 and R11,R12. 
      The voltage difference between the grid input signal and cathode
      feedback signal is amplified 47 times 
      by the 6SL7 and applied to the network beginning with C5. 
      The network after C5 has a shelved response at LF and HF to reduce
      the 6SL7 gain and phase shift 
      at frequencies where otherwise oscillations might occur below 10Hz
      or above 60kHz because of the 
      use of the global NFB. 
      The 6SL7 is among the world's most linear triodes and easily
      produces the 15Vrms at very low THD 
      required by the next EL34 driver stage. V2 Driver stage, EL34. 
      The EL34 is triode connected and has a gain of about 8.7, close to
      the µ of EL34. I had hoped to use 
      a choke plus resistance to feed the EL34 with anode dc so that
      this gave a high impedance dc feed to 
      the tube but there was no room to put any filter chokes, and very
      little time to do it. In 2008 I created 
      a +750V supply rail for the EL34, and used a simple 25k resistance
      R13 to convey Idc to the anode 
      via R13. 
      The following grid bias R17, 47k, is bootstrapped to the cathode
      FB winding at near 0V potential. 
      This causes the its loading value on EL34 anode to effectively
      appear as approximately 203, and the 
      total anode load for EL34 becomes 25k in parallel with 200k in
      parallel giving total of 22k. 
      The EL34 has Ia = 16mA, and Ea = 320V approx, and maximum anode
      signal = 180Vrms at 
      about 2.5% of mainly 2H. 130Vrms is needed to drive the 13E1 grid
      to clipping level and at this 
      level the EL34 produces only about 1.8% 2H distortion and it could
      not be made more linear easily. 
      This 2H has a phase relationship with fundamental frequency such
      that there is substantial cancellation 
      of the 2H produced in the output stage, and most most effectively
      where loads are less than rated 
      nominal, when output stage distortion becomes highest. All SE amps
      where you have a single ended 
      triode driving a single ended output tube do have some distortion
      cancellation naturally occurring 
      between the two stages. Usually the 2H cancellation does not
      result in a useful amount of 2H reduction 
      because output tube THD is typically 4 times that of the driver
      tube at all levels up to clipping. 
      
      In this amp and the SE35, the use of local CFB windings on the OPT
      in the output stage reduces the 
      output stage distortion to similar percentages to that of the
      driver stage and at all levels so the 
      cancellation then becomes a very effective way of reducing
      distortion without having to use global NFB 
      to reduce the distortion. The benefits of the CFB are similar to
      the benefits of 2H current cancellation 
      in PP balanced amps, but in this SE case there is voltage
      cancellation instead of current cancellation.
      In the SEUL, global NFB is about 16dB, so all distortions get
      reduced by a factor of about 1/6. 
      So where there is no global NFB, there may be 6% THD, including
      slight 2H cancelling between 
      driver and output stage. 
      
      When GNFB is added, THD is then reduced to just under 1%. In the
      case of amps with substantial 
      amounts of CFB such as the SE32 here (and SE35), the THD without
      GNFB varies with load value 
      but is kept under 1.5% for a range of useful loads because the THD
      of the driver tube cancels the low 
      THD of the output stage for low loads where most THD occurs. Such
      2H cancellation is impossible 
      with a pure beam tetrode, pentode, triode or UL stage without
      local CFB because all such output 
      stages have over 5% THD without CFB, and the driver triode does
      not make enough THD for any 
      significant cancellations, and in fact the IMD produced in the two
      stages without any NFB at all 
      probably sounds worse than where THD reduction in the OP stage is
      achieved within the OP stage.
      
      Trouble understanding that? Let us assume we have just two
      hypothetical amp stages in cascade, 
      driver and output stages, where OP tube gain = 2.3 times which is
      the low gain of an OP tube 
      with a lot of CFB present. Gain with CFB = Va-k / Vg-0V.
      
      Consider the operation at medium power levels well under clipping.
      Consider Va-k = 230Vrms 
      anode to cathode signal applied to an OPT and there is 1.0% of 2H
      present. The 2H signal = 
      2.3Vrms. Suppose the driver stage also produces 1.0% 2H, where its
      anode voltage is say 100Vrms 
      which is applied to the OP tube grid. The 1.0% 2H = 1.0Vrms. The
      output stage amplifies the 
      100Vrms of grid signal to produce Va-k = 230Vrms, and also
      amplifies the driver tube 2H of 
      1.0Vrms to produce 2.3Vrms of 2H. In such a hypothetical
      situation, if the amplified 2H from a 
      driver tube equals the 2H produced by an OP tube are equal, then
      complete cancellation of 2H 
      occurs and no 2H is to be measured. Magic seems to have occurred.
      
      
      In practice, if you have TWO lots of 2H signals present, and if
      the RELATIVE PHASE of 2H to 
      fundamental frequency produced in driver is the same as that
      produced in the OP tube then the 
      phase inversion that occurs in the OP tube will cause the two lots
      of 2H signals to have opposite 
      phase, so there will theoretically be the difference between the
      two lots of 2H at the output of the 
      output stage. 
      
      The actual difference is slightly affected by phase shifts caused
      by C and L effects in couplings and 
      OPT, but the reduction in 2H may be very substantial. However, 2H
      cancelling with tetrode or 
      pentode OP stages using NFB has limitations because the 2H
      relative phase in such tubes is same 
      as a driver triode where OP anode loads are low, and then become
      opposite at high OP anode loads. 
      
      The 2H of tetrode/pentode tubes is high at low RLa loads, then
      reduces to zero at some middle 
      RLa, then increases as RLa goes higher, and with relative phase
      that is opposite to use of low loads. 
      ( The tetrode/pentode OP tube also produces considerable 3H and
      other H, but cancellation 
      techniques cannot be easily used to cancel  odd numbered H )
      
      The cancellation of 2H between input, driver, and output tubes is
      all we ever might want to achieve, 
      because its all that is easily possible. The major benefit of
      using CFB in an OP stage is to reduce ALL 
      H products by a large amount and H cancellation is an "accidental"
      benefit, ie, an "electronic freebie" 
      which is nice to have, but not absolutely necessary. But the use
      CFB allows amplifier Rout to be 
      reduced so much little global NFB is needed to reduce it
      further.  Therefore GNFB need only be 9dB 
      and all distortion is reduced by a factor of 0.36. Typical THD of
      a CFB amp may be much lower 
      than an SEUL or triode amp but while using 1/2 the amount of GNFB.
      
      
      Usually the CFB amp has lower Rout, ie, much better damping
      factor. Distortion measures much 
      lower with CFB for low value loads. V3 Output stage has the 13E1
      set up as a beam tetrode with a 
      screen Eg2 = +175Vdc, Ea = +475V, and Ia = 155mA, for a Pda =
      73.6W. 
      
      The screen heat dissipation, Pdg2, is very low because the 13EI
      was designed to operate with low 
      screen voltages under +200Vdc with anode voltages of up to 800V.
      With such low screen voltage 
      the screen current at idle is also low, and less than half what it
      is when using 13E1 in UL or triode 
      mode which is unsafe if Ea and hence Eg2 exceed +375Vdc. I have an
      OPT cathode winding 
      devoted to giving 33% of the total Va-k signal as local cathode
      voltage feedback in series with the g
      rid input signal. 
      
      So why was CFB = 33% where 12% to 20% would be plenty? 
      When I wound the OPT for these amps in 1997, I used the following
      recipe which remains in the 
      SE32 2012 version :- 
      Core = double C-cores with strip width = 55mm, and build up =
      36mm, 
      low grade GOSS which was all I could obtain locally in 1997. Max µ
      = 4,500 without a gap, 
      but with a gap µe is about 350. 
      The air gap was set so 200mAdc would magnetize the core to about
      0.6Tesla. 
      The Primary is 1,800 turns in 3 sections of 600 turns each with
      the center section subdivided to 
      give two 200 turn windings and two 100 turn windings to allow a
      variation of screen connection 
      points for UL and for future arrangements. 
      The Secondary has 4 sections interleaved symmetrically with the 3
      P sections, giving an interleaving 
      pattern of 4S x 3P, or S-P-S-P-S-P-S. 
      Each S section is a single layer of 57 turns each, with the last
      on section divided into 3 sub sections 
      of 19t each, and the arrangement allows :-
      4 parallel 57t secs for 2k8 : 2r8,
      3 parallel 76t secs, for 2k8 : 5r0,
      2 parallel 114t secs, for 2k8 : 11r24 
      
      The 2.8k to 5r0 match was selected for the above schematic, 1,800
      P turns to 76 S turns. 
      It was decided that all of the center P section of 600 turns would
      be used for a CFB winding which 
      has one end taken to 0V. I could have used 1/2 the center P
      section for 16.5% CFB and this would 
      have resulted in only 50Vrms cathode FB and an easier drive
      voltage of about 80Vrms at the grid. 
      
      But then I would have had a high Vdc potential between two
      adjacent P layers of turns without 
      enough P to P insulation thickness, and to avoid the risk of dc
      arcing, I used the whole center section 
      of P turns. In any case, the amp is used at low levels for hi-fi
      where average signals are 1/10 of the 
      peak signals, and well away from high distortion levels. 
      
      The best screen arrangement took a day to work out. At first I
      just had the screen going to a fixed 
      voltage of +150Vdc above the cathode, as the data on this tube
      says Eg2 at +150V is OK even 
      though Ea might be 5 times this voltage. The 13E1 was designed at
      a time when designers tried to 
      produce beam tetrodes which did not need a high screen voltage or
      screen current for mainly 
      economic and efficiency reasons, but also for better reliability
      with less voltage and current involved. 
      
      It is mainly luck that the 13E1 works in triode mode or UL mode at
      all because in these modes the 
      screen is at the same potential as the anode and the limits for
      the Ea are determined by the effect 
      screen voltage has on its current draw, and the screen dissipation
      ratings. 
      
      So Ea = +375Vdc is the maximum for the 13E1 in triode or UL. 
      With a high Eg2, Eg1 must be increased to control the idle Idc,
      and with SEUL the Eg1 must be 
      about -80Vdc, and any further increase of Ea and Eg2 beyond +375V
      results in the likelihood 
      of the grid g1 losing control of the idle current. 
      
      With CFB, you could have Ea much higher, perhaps +800V which would
      be useful in a push pull 
      amps and then a pair could produce an output power in class AB1 of
      well over over 200W with 
      a few initial W of pure class A. PP operation would be better with
      Ea no higher than used for 
      4 x KT88/6550, ie, about 500Vdc, to give 100W max, with at least
      30W of initial pure class A.
      
      The 2k8 anode load for 13E1 was chosen to give a match for maximum
      clipping power into 5r0, 
      and then Ea adjusted from available taps on the HT winding to suit
      the wanted load. 
      
      Now for all beam tetrodes and pentodes:-
      Load RLa for maximum power approximately = 0.9 x Ea/Ia. 
      Pda at the anode = Ea x Ia, so Ia = Pda / Ea, so RL = 0.9 x Ea
      squared / Pda. 
      In this case the load was selected at 2,800 ohms.
      So 2,800 = 0.9 x Ea squared / 73.6, so Ea = 478.51Vdc. 
      With Pda = 73.6 maximum, Ia = Pda / Ea = 73.6 / 478.5 = 153 mA. In
      practice, these Ea and 
      Ia calculations proved to be very near correct. 
      
      At first I tried to have the screen supplied with a fixed Vdc
      voltage at 150Vdc above the cathode Vdc. 
      But  I found that with 33% of primary turns at the cathode
      and 66% at the anode, the cathode voltage 
      would swing upwards and so close to the fixed screen voltage that
      the tube would go into cut off and 
      the distortion became high, and power limited to less than SEUL. 
      So I then connected the earthy end of the screen supply to
      available tapping points on the cathode 
      winding which was wound with these taps to allow varied UL % taps.
      
      
      The best outcome was when the screen was bypassed to the CT of the
      CFB winding, or at 16.5% of 
      the total primary turns. This meant the minimum voltage between
      screen and cathode was well above 
      the threshold for Ia cut off caused by Eg2 becoming too low. 
      
      Then as a double measure I raised the Eg2 supply slightly to
      +175Vdc above the cathode and no 
      premature "cut off distortion" could occur at any load value. The
      final result gives 32W and much more 
      than triode strapping and more than SEUL and much less THD and
      lower Rout. So the screen 
      connection method and Eg2 remains high enough at all times to have
      its proper influence on the electron 
      stream. There are actually TWO local NFB circuits. 
      
      Any distortion voltage between anode and cathode appears at both
      anode and cathode but in a ratio 
      of +2 : -1 respectively. So if anode distortion voltage Vdn =
      +2Vdn there is -1Vdn at cathode because the
      OPT anode winding has 2/3 of Pri turns and cathode has 1/3. The
      THD between a and k = +3Vdn. 
      So there is a +1Vdn signal between grid and cathode and if the
      inverting open loop gain 
      = -10 for Va-k / Vg-k, then error signal grid between a and k =
      +1Vdn x -10 = -10Vdn.
      
      This seems impossible because measured THD from a to k = 3Vdn,
      less than calculated error Va-k.
      But this is why NFB is hard to understand. What really is
      happening that THD with no NFB will 
      be about +13Vdn from a to k, and this is reduced by -10Vdn to give
      resulting +3Vdn. 
      Thus the open loop THD may be reduced from say 13% with no NFB to
      3% with the local cathode FB. 
      Usually there is slightly more THD reduction because of the Vdn
      between screen and cathode also 
      is amplified to reduce the open loop THD.
      
      I found that for Va-k signal = +300Vac, Vg-k = -30Vac, and the
      Vg-0V needed = -130Vrms, so 
      the gain reduction factor for CFB = 30V / 130V = 0.23, which is
      about 12dB of applied NFB.
      
      In class A with the RLa = 2k8, the THD of output stage < 2% at
      near clipping at 31W. 
      If the screen was fully bypassed to cathode, the 13E1 would work
      as pure beam tetrode with 33% NFB 
      and open loop gain would be higher so applied NFB might be about
      17dB.
      But with screen fed by 16.5% of Va-k, the tube acts as though it
      has 16.5% UL connection but with 33% 
      CFB.  For where CFB > 20%, the screen Vac is needed to
      prevent cut off and THD is lowest and 
      THD spectra least venemous for the music.
      
      Beam tetrode effective Ra' may be calculated = Ra' = Ra / ( 1 + [
      µ x ß ] ) where Ra is for no NFB,
      1 is a constant, µ = amplification factor, ß = fraction fed back.
      For 13E1 with Ra = 10.6k, µ = 220, and ß = 0.33, Ra' = 10,600r / (
      1 + [ 220 x 0.33] ) = 144r, a huge 
      reduction and less than 1/2 Ra for triode connection. 
      But with the screen taken to a tap and fed with some signal of
      opposite phase to the anode, the internal 
      tube gain condition is equal to working with a 16.5% ultralinear
      tapping, and this is enough to reduce 
      the high beam tetrode µ to much lower much lower UL µ = 12.8 with
      UL Ra = 1.56k. 
      When 33% CFB is used, the Ra' is 300r. With OPT ratio of 2k8 :
      5r0, ZR = 560 : 1, and Rout at sec 
      = 300 / 560 = 0.54r. The sec winding resistance may be about 5% =
      0.25r so total Rout = 0.79r.
      The 9dB of global FB reduces this output resistance to 0.32 ohms
      giving a damping factor of over 9 even 
      with a 3r0 load.
      
      The easier and simpler way to set up the 13E1 tube is to have a
      fixed Eg2 = +175V, and this means the 
      screen +Vdc supply = (175V + Ek ) and if Ek across cathode bias
      network = +33Vdc, then the screen 
      supply = 175V + 33V = +208Vdc above 0V.
      
      All previous operation is for 13E1 with the OPT I wound in 1997. 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Better operation for 13E1 is possible with better OPT with 20%
      CFB, with fixed screen Vdc rail at + 208Vdc,  
      with idle Ea = 372Vdc, Ek = 33Vdc, B+ = +417Vdc, Ia = 186mAdc, Pda
      = 69W, and Pdg2 = low. 
      
      The same idle Ea and Iadc can be used for 66% UL, but Eg2 will be
      equal to Ea, so Eg1 bias would be about 
      83Vdc, so that for Ek = 33V the Rk for cathode biasing = 33V / (
      Iadc + Ig2dc ). Maybe Rk = 165r. 
      To get the Eg1-k bias correct, a -50Vdc fixed bias supply is
      needed for 13E1 g1. UL Pda = 71W,
      and UL Po will be slightly less than for CFB. 
      
      CFB operation is best and gives highest anode efficiency of about
      46% and least wasted heat on the screen.
      
      
      With a fixed g2 Vdc rail, the CFB turns on OPT should not be less
      than 12.5% or more than 20% of total 
      primary turns. Here is a possible OPT design :- 
      Fig 2. 32W SE OPT for 13E1.
      
      The above OPT has 15 layers of 0.4mm primary wire which allows
      Iadc up to 0.25Adc where max 
      idc current density = 2A / sq.mm. 
      3 of the 15 primary layers may be used for a CFB winding. You may
      expect to need max Vac to g1 
      = 75Vrms for Va = 190Vrms and Vk = 46Vrms. The 13E1 will operate
      with open loop gain similar to 
      20% UL, but effect of 20% CFB gives quite enough NFB to reduce
      effective Ra to less than triode 
      connection. 
      3 x KT88 or 6550 could be used with RLa for each then being 5k4,
      and I suspect outcome would 
      be quite excellent compared to a single 13E1.
      
      The single 13E1 with CFB using Eg2 much lower than Ea can have
      idle Pda up to about 75W and 46% 
      anode efficiency yields 34.5W at anode, and if OPT loss = 10%,
      expect 31W at speaker terminals.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      For tyhe 2008 version od SE32 with 13E1, I placed the PT away from
      the OPT and used best core 
      positions to prevent any significant stray magnetic coupling. The
      local CFB and global NFB reduces 
      whatever small amount of stray magnetic coupling exists. Use of
      mild steel boxes to pot the OPT 
      and PT separately definitely reduce any possibility of magnetic
      coupling. The measured THD of the 
      completed SE32 was very much like the results I obtained with the
      SE35, and well below the THD 
      for SEUL22. The reasons for low THD in 2008 and 2012 versions of
      SE32 and SE35 is due to 
      significant but naturally unforced 2H distortion cancellation
      between the driver stage and output stage. 
      So there is little point to me publishing the THD graphs I
      obtained for the SE32, and THD for SE32 
      and SE35 is similar to good PP amps which usually have much lower
      THD than most SE amps.
      
      If there is local CFB in the SE output stage in class A, most
      distortion reduction is done in the output 
      stage, so the error correction signal being amplified by input and
      driver stages is very low, so the IMD 
      otherwise generated by having only GNFB is much reduced. 
      To avoid the input and driver stages contributing much THD to the
      total, the input stage should be a 
      paralleled twin triode, and can be high µ such as 6SL7, or similar
      but smaller 12AY7, or a 12AT7.
      
      I found EL34 to work very well as a triode driver tube and it has
      gain 8.7 in schematic above, and it 
      easily generates the maximum 130Vrms for output stage with 33%
      CFB.
      
      But where CFB = 20%, then max Va from driver = 75Vrms, and
      although EL34 is excellent, EL84 
      will work just fine. 
      
      Everyone should know all triodes have inbuilt and unavoidable
      natural internal electrostatic shunt feedback.
      The amount of applied NFB within any triode varies with its gain
      and is maximum where triode gain 
      = triode amplification factor, µ. This can only occur where the
      Iac change = 0.0ma, even where the Vac 
      may be quite high, and a typical SE EL34 set up in triode mode
      with a CCS anode load may produce 
      100Vrms with THD < 1%, or 0.1% at 10Vrms, and this level of
      linearity without external loops of NFB 
      make triodes the the most naturally linear device in the universe.
      When operated with some external loop 
      FB from resistance network or transformer windings, linearity just
      gets better. There is plenty of electrostatic 
      shunt NFB in the input and driver triodes of the SE32 because
      their gain is high due to high anode load 
      values so that gain approaches µ. 
      Therefore the SE32 will work well without the global NFB if it is
      really not wanted, especially where the 
      speaker load = 8r0 and OPT set for 3r8 load. The damping factor
      would be fine without the global NFB
      and THD low enough, and sensitivity would increase so that
      clipping level needs only 0.32Vrms input.
      In SE32 there is only 9dB of global NFB, a tiny amount compared to
      the typical 60dB around a typical 
      solid state amp. The numerical difference is between 3 times to
      1,000 times. 
      
      If ever anyone were to try to use the 13EI ( or 3 x 6550 ) in pure
      beam tetrode without any FB but with 
      the above dc operation and anode loading, the THD at onset of
      clipping may reach 10%. 
      Alll beam tetrodes and pentodes are like this. 13EI open loop gain
      would be maybe 40 though, so there is 
      lots of gain that can be easily be reduced with linear external
      NFB networks of resistance or transformer 
      windings. The linear CFB path around the CFB stage is more linear
      than the internal NFB within a triode 
      which obeys rate of Iac change proportional Vac x cube root of a
      constant squared, and triodes only really 
      become very linear when there is minimal Ia change. But in a power
      output tube a lot of Ia change must 
      occur because there is real work to be done at a speaker. So a
      beam tetrode or pentode makes sense,
      and their gain allows external linear NFB loops, and it is easily
      driven by a triode which makes high Vac 
      but has low Iac. As long as the driver tube doesn't go anywhere
      near clipping, the total outcome will 
      produce low distortion. I would never intend using more than 33%
      CFB because as the % increases, the 
      driver THD can become high, and driver begins to contribute more
      THD to output than the output stage. 
      
      Those wanting to use all 9 pin mini tubes instead of octals for
      the driver amp should consider the input with 
      a parallel 6CG7 and 3 parallel EL84 for driver as seen at Deep Space 845. 
       
      The 13E1 cathode needs over 30W of heating. This radiates heat to
      anode. The anode can have up to 
      70W idle Pda so that the heat radiating through glass is a total
      of 100W. The 13E1 data give Pda max 
      = 90W but never ever idle the rube at Pda = 90W becase total heat
      = 120W and I found anodes glow 
      cherry red at Pda 90W. In a PP amp with idle Pda = 20W, allowing
      max Pda to to reach 90W with Vac 
      operation is OK because where music peaks are just beginning to
      clip, average output Po = 1/10 of 
      rated maximum possible with a sine wave. 
      But an SE tube works hard with Pda at 70W if 32W of pure class A
      is wanted. I fitted two 13E1 
      in a pair of SE amps in 1997 and after an estimated 7,000 hours
      they still measured low THD gave full Po 
      like new tubes. They did develop some positive idle Vdc at their
      grids which indicated there were some 
      gas molecules inside the tube and the gettering was not able to
      absorb them all. The use of low value grid 
      biasing resistors not exceeding 47k does tend to prevent the
      positive grid current at idle from going too 
      high, thus turning on the tube which makes it hotter, thus
      generating even more positive Vdc at grids. 
      
      For the SE32 the stability depended on gain shelving networks
      between V1 and V2, so networks are needed 
      for LF stability with C9+R8, and HF stability with C7+R9, C10, and
      Zobel at output with C16+R24. 
      This all worked with the OPT I used, but it will NOT work with a
      different OPT. 
      Fig 3. PSU for 2008 SE32. 
      
      In Fig 3 above, there is a total of 4,700uF for the main 500V B+
      supply filtering. 
      There are no filter chokes, and they are not needed in this case
      if there are enough R+C filter 
      networks in series. The R values can be low, so heat in R is kept
      fairly low, and ripple Vac at OPT 
      B+ connection = 2.8mV. However, R12 and R16 were mounted on a heat
      sink to keep their temp 
      low because they each dissipate 4.5W. Each of R12 and R16 are 5 x
      820 x 10W in parallel. 
      
      The +780Vdc at the top of C3 is developed by means of a 1/2 wave
      voltage doubler working from 
      the +500V main doubler rectifier for the anode supply current. The
      +780V is made by the doubler 
      formed with C11, and two 1N5408, and feeds C3 through R15, and
      peak charge currents are low, 
      and don't affect the switching of the anode diodes for the main
      anode supply. 
      
      If anything in the EL34 shorts to 0V, the cheap R will burn open
      before the circuit produces smoke 
      from the PT. A short in the main 515Vdc anode supply will blow the
      mains fuse. Active protection 
      has been fitted to the SE32 circuit to guard against excessive Ia
      in 13EI, but has not been drawn up 
      yet. 
      It has a simple RC filter using 4.7k from the cathode to a 470uF
      cap to reduce the ac voltage but 
      allow the Vdc at the cathode to be divided down further by a
      resistance network and applied to a 
      C106D sensitive gate SCR. If the cathode Vdc rises to 50Vdc, Idc
      in the tube would be 217mA, 
      and Ea would drop by about 25Vdc, making Pda = about 93Watts, and
      the tube would show 
      some red and be over stressed, but able to cope for a short time.
      At Vdc at cathode = 50V, 
      the SCR is arranged to turn on, causing a relay to open in the HT
      winding on the PT so that the 
      whole anode supply is turned right off, and no damage is
      sustained. With such a small Ia change 
      involved between correct operation and a fault condition, active
      protection which has precision which
      ordinary fuses cannot provide. Owners are notorious for fitting
      the wrong value of fuse after a fuse 
      blows, and therefore causing much more expensive damage. My
      protect circuits can be triggered if 
      there is a shorted speaker load connected, or if bias failure or
      tube failure from any reason occurs, 
      and the amp may be re-set by turning off, then back on. Repeating
      fault conditions mean the amp 
      needs a visit to a capable technician. 
      
      The amps now have a blue "on" LED, and a red LED turns on when a
      fault occurs.  The 6SL7 has 
      a dc supply to its heater as shown to minimize its hum. Those
      wanting a similar gain and Ra and 
      wonderful sound and less hum but from a 9 pin tube could use a
      12AY7, or 12AT7.
      
      To 
      SE32, 2012
          version 
         SEUL25, 1997
         power amps directory  
        Index page